Author: Ash Nallawalla

About Ash Nallawalla

Ash Nallawalla is a consultant enterprise SEO with a long background in large companies with complex websites. He is a published author of several books and thousands of magazine articles.

SpeedPPC 3 Review

Reading Time: 4 minutes

by Ash Nallawalla
Click to enlarge
When I first read the description of SpeedPPC and saw the price of $497, my immediate thought was that this product was too cheap. I had seen an online service that charges a relatively higher, recurring fee to do what SpeedPPC 3 does for a one-time fee. I nearly told SpeedPPC creator Jay Stockwell that he is nuts – actually I met him at Pubcon 2007 and I suggested more diplomatically that he should check out what the competition is charging for less functionality. He gave me a sneak peek at the beta version 3, which is still being polished as we speak. Here is my report.

By now you must be wondering what the hell is SpeedPPC and do you care about it. If you do not use pay-per-click (PPC*) ads to advertise on Google AdWords, Yahoo! Search Marketing or Microsoft adCenter, then you won’t care about the rest of this review.

* which Google misleadingly refers to as “SEM” although SEM includes SEO, but that’s another story.

What Is SpeedPPC?

SpeedPPC is both a system and a methodology. It is not a single program but a set of Windows program, website templates and PHP scripts.

Dynamic Creatives

SpeedPPC takes your list of keyphrases (Google calls them keywords) and enables you to multiply them into additional combinations, e.g. “dentist” can be combined with a list of suburbs, e.g. “dentist richmond”, “dentist kew” and so on. This known as the “dual core” method. You can specify different bids for Exact, Phrase and Broad Match. SpeedPPC also creates the creatives, which are the actual ads you see on the ad network and their partner sites.

You can upload the creatives and the keywords with their bids using the Google AdWords Editor. The SpeedPPC campaign builder will also build your Microsoft adCenter campaigns, but you’ll need to use their online interface to add them (via a bulk upload CSV file).

Click to enlargeThe next important feature is that you can create a unique landing page that uses each keyphrase prominently. This keeps the Google Quality Score as high as possible, which gives you the cheapest cost per click. This feature is not entirely in the SpeedPPC package as such, but in a separately downloadable PHP script and matching templates. You install the script and it gives you a custom page for each keyword.

For example, to create the templated landing page at left, you embed the HTML inside the supplied PHP script, then you call it from the ad network’s Destination URL with a call such as:

http://www.example.com/template-speedppc.php?seed=Car-Parts&expansion=all-car-parts&final=car-parts-america

Click the above image to see where the above variables end up in the template.

Click to enlargeA closely related feature is the Affiliate datafeed landing page creator. This enables you to have a unique keyword and landing page pair per product in the datafeed (see image to the right) – affiliate heaven!

You upload the supplied script and make a MySQL database on your Linux server and follow the simple instructions to upload your datafeed file.

A fine set of narrated videos help you to understand the product very quickly. PDF manuals are also provided.

What’s New?

  • The first thing you notice about SpeedPPC 3 is the completely changed interface.
  • The next feature I noticed is that I could load a campaign of over 30,000 keywords, whereas the first release was limited to 1900. The next improvement is the speed! With the old version, processing 1900 keywords took more than 30 minutes and it was not advisable to load large campaigns. This version pumps out the 30,000 keywords in as little as three minutes! You should not normally need to run such large campaigns, but I was trying to test its limits.
  • Yahoo! Search Marketing support is now included, which will please many advertisers who run campaigns on Yahoo. Microsoft adCenter support is still present, so all the three biggies have been covered.
  • Advanced Ad Building enables you to mixmaster your headlines, description lines and display URLs. SpeedPPC will build text ads that represent every permutation of these.
  • We all need to copy ads and modify them. Now you can copy them from one box to another with the click of a button.
  • The Keyword Library enables you to reuse the same keyword lists for new campaigns. The benefits are obvious.
  • You can clean up keywords, say, by removing invalid characters or extra spaces. For experienced users, there is an option to remove all spaces between keyphrases, which results in joined words. Why would you want this, you may well ask. Some people accidentally run two words together in a search query and if you target competitive niches such as debt consolidation, this little trick could get you a few cheap clicks.
  • The My Campaigns panel displays all your SpeedPPC projects in one window even if they are stored in different directories on the PC. This is useful if you need to organise your PC to suit campaigns or different clients, instead of having to place all of them in one directory.
  • Certain tasks such as Excel export can take a few minutes to complete, but you can open a fresh instance of SpeedPPC and build a new campaign simultaneously. No more coffee breaks for the staff!
  • You can export your campaign in CSV format and now in Excel too.
  • The status bar shows the total quantity of seed and expansion keywords

Conclusion

SpeedPPC 3 is a powerful tool for PPC advertisers, particularly those with thousands of keywords and who are targeting multiple locations for each keyword. Although there are many free tools to mix keywords with another variable, they don’t address the tricky issue of building unique landing pages for each unique keyword. Not only will this improve the Google Quality Score, it will be a better user experience and, therefore, it should lead to more conversions. If you are a regular PPC advertiser, you should grab a copy before Jay wakes up and raises the price.

Product home page: www.speedppc.com

A pox on reciprocal link requests (with free clues)

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Some people need to buy a clue or two. I get a couple of link requests most days. I don’t even open them but I took a look at today’s example:

I have visited your site and I think that the content could be of interest to our web site visitors.
If you feel that you would be interested in exchanging links please go to [url], here you will be able to enter your websites details into the appropiate category.

Please ensure that the reciprocal URL that is entered is working properly, otherwise the program will decline the exchange.

Our details are as follows:

Site URL: [url]
Site Title: [snip]
Site Description: [snip]

.. or use this HTML:

[snip]

If you have any other cross-promotion ideas, please let me know.

Please note that the link on our website can take upto 72 hours to be visable, due to the updating of the system.

Best regards,

Dear clueless Indian link monkey,

If you took the trouble to tell me which of my 65 websites you are referring to, you might have a chance of filling your day’s quota of links. How do I know you are from India? Apart from the IP address originating in India, you used the unique Indian English word “upto”. The rest of the world knows it as two words “up to”. Look it up in a dictionary.

The second free clue is that I have no websites concerning your client’s topic. Your boss seems to conduct “linking campaigns” for clients based on quantity, not quality. However, my giving your client a link from an off-topic page will do nothing for either of us and will lessen the relevance of my page for its topic. Your boss probably knows this, but business is business, right?

The third free clue is that not all websites have a free-form “links” page where they can conveniently drop your HTML. Many of my sites use Joomla and its built-in links component gives indirect links that don’t help SEO.

The fourth free clue is that the link anchor text needs to be varied, so giving others the HTML and anchor text will give your client a few identically worded links. This won’t help the client.

The last free clue is that your spellings suck. Many people won’t notice it, but the ones who do will be less inclined to play.

Google offers SEO services

Reading Time: < 1 minute

Would you believe Google:

scientifically optimizes existing client sites to create new, dynamic, crawler-friendly sites highlighting brand, nonbrand and long-tail keywords. Our experts methodically optimize copy and content for each page to boost page rankings.

It is true, in a roundabout way. Google now owns DoubleClick, whose Performics service delivers SEO services. Danny Sullivan has written an open letter to Google urging the latter to divest itself of Performics, owing to a conflict of service.

At the moment I’d hate to be a Performics customer if my rankings were below my expectations. I can just imagine the following fictitious conversation:

Customer: You are Google, so why isn’t my site ranking #1 for all my keywords? Don’t you know how to optimise for Google?

Performics: Sir, we are now owned by Google but we cannot influence search results to favour our own clients. We have delivered the best-practice SEO to your one-page website, which is about debt consolidation. That is a very competitive niche.

Customer: So what can you do to get me to #1 for “debt consolidation”?

Performics: Sir, Google’s Guidelines for Webmasters tells you not to use an SEO service that guarantees a top ranking. We can build some more pages, align existing content to search queries, and get you some more quality links, but we can’t guarantee a #1 ranking.

Customer: Why not?

Performics: Matt Cutts.

and so on.

Fortunately, Google has responded to Danny’s concerns. Read his open letter to get the rest of the picture.

Amex does a favour to the SEO profession

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Thanks to a sensational headline by Webpronews – American Express Guide Calls SEOs A “Waste”, the SEO profession might be pleased to know that American Express has done them an inadvertent favour.

The facts are a little less sensational. Amex USA sponsors an initiative called OPEN, which helps small businesses by getting them to meet locally via meetup.com. They sponsored a few publications to be made available from the OPEN meetup page. As happens in large companies, such publishing initiatives are a brief project in someone’s quarterly schedule and there isn’t time to check the contents of documents that were produced by external agencies:

The OPEN BOOK is a 96-page document containing contributions from several Amex experts and external agencies. I don’t think the book’s editors would see it their role to question assertions such as the following from the Cuban Council on page 59:

7. OPTIMIZE YOUR SEARCH ENGINES

Search engines, like Yahoo! and Google, are usually the first place people will look for you. Make it easier for them to find you. Yahoo! and Google offer tools to let them know the site map structure of your Web site. Also, using clean U.R.L.’s like yourdomain.com/store/widgets instead of yourdomain.com/store.php?id=42&categoryID=widgets will increase your chances of getting indexed in a search engine. Finally, don’t waste money on so-called Search Engine Optimization (S.E.O.) specialists. Search engines are very quick to penalize sites that try to trick their filtering techniques, and once your site has been put on Google’s blacklist, it will take forever to get off.

What a set of generalisations, purporting to be SEO advice? What was the writer trying to achieve here?

Another smaller document from OPEN is Marketing Your Business on Search Engines, a well-written document, clearly not by the previous author or publisher. It says, in part:

Maximizing your search engine marketing and optimization effectiveness may take more than just an employee with an aptitude for the Web. You may decide it is necessary to hire an experienced partner. Use these criteria to make an informed choice: (a list follows)

Now this is contradictory, but correct advice. In the other document, the youthful “Cuban Council” has its own agenda, being a web design company full of cool people who were perhaps only warning about “so-called” SEO specialists. The problem is that they did not tell the reader how to distinguish a so-called specialist from the real thing.

Therefore, the poor small-business person will be left with conflicting advice from the same page. They will probably get their website built by some cool young people who are unlikely to incorporate any SEO features beyond “meta tags” (every cool web designer knows about meta tags). Web design briefs almost never include any off-page factors.

Why is this a favour to SEOs from Amex?

My frequent refrain is, “The ignorance of web designers is the bread-and-butter of the SEO profession.” While business owners continue to buy websites from SEO-ignorant web designers/developers, their sites will always be in need of proper search engine optimisation. The better-informed business owners with their optimised websites will benefit because there will be less competition in the search engine results. Thank you, American Express.

AddedSEW picked up this story over a month ago.

Experimental Google Search Interface

Reading Time: < 1 minute

Click to enlargeGoogle has been testing a simplified new interface in Australia for Advanced Search. I haven’t seen any mentions of it from people in North America or elsewhere.

The top of the form seems friendlier:

Find web pages that have…

all these words:
this exact wording or phrase:
one or more of these words:

But don’t show pages that have…

any of these unwanted words:

Need more tools?

Results per page:
Language:
File type:
Search within a site or domain:

Then a collapsible area for “Date, usage rights, numeric range and more”.

It is currently visible at 72.14.253.104, 72.14.253.99, 72.14.253.103, and 72.14.253.147. This has only been seen for google.com, not google.com.au. I think Google has made the right call for me at least, as I rarely use the options that have been collapsed.

GTrends free tool finds keyphrases with low competition

Reading Time: < 1 minute

I attended an informative talk by Glen Staiger about his experience with the “30 Day Challenge”, which included a mention of the free Wordtracker tool known as GTrends. It is a keyphrase competitiveness research tool, which is an extension of the free Wordtracker search tool.

My friend had blogged about Iron Maiden’s videos taken during their recent Indian tour and this had swelled his visitor count (briefly) by a huge number that I won’t reveal. So I used some Iron Maiden related phrases to test GTrends.

To check any keyphrase, type it in the Keyword field and look at the results:

GTrends result

Click to enlargeClick the bar graph icon on the right of any keyphrase and you will get a popup like the image to the right (click it to enlarge). If both bars (representing Google Competition – the number of results is less than 30k – and the number of Google visitors per day is more than 140) are green, then this is a keyphrase worthy of more research.

Now the count for Iron Maiden Tour in the popup is a lot more than 25, which I can’t explain, but I created a small blog to monitor its traffic. The above is the only link I am giving it, although it might attract one or two from elsewhere as I populate the blog later on. Check out the free tool!

SEO implication of new social networking sites

Reading Time: < 1 minute

In the past two days my contacts and best friends have invited me to join:

  • Konnects
  • Ziki
  • hi5
  • Assorted groups in BlogCatalog, Facebook and LinkedIn

In the past few weeks there were invitations to other sites I had not heard of. There are networking addicts who join everything that comes along. Some of these sites allow you to import an existing profile, such as from LinkedIn, which is such a tempting feature for the networking junkies.

SEO Implication

I see all this as a big duplicate content risk for the wannabe social networking sites. When most of the members post the same profile on numerous sites, do you seriously think that Google’s algo will let this content be displayed above the established sites? Ideally, the profile acceptance process should include a Google query to check for duplicate content, and then it should ask the member to submit a unique resume.

Best WordPress “Highlight Author Comments” plugin

Reading Time: < 1 minute

Thanks to a comment following Matt Cutts’ post on this topic, I tried a couple of plugins and realised that my understanding of PHP was nonexistent and I could not follow the directions of their authors. Thankfully, Chris Hunt posted a link to a plugin by Rob Marsh, SJ (a Jesuit priest in a teaching order like we had in my old alma mater, St Xavier’s Boys’ Academy, Bombay). This plugin is dead easy to implement – just enable it and go to Options and edit the CSS statement to change the background colour, as per the readme file provided. The default CSS statement merely achieves an indent, which isn’t as striking as changing the background colour.

URL for plugin: Highlight Author Comments

Double Whammy for Domain Name Tasters

Reading Time: 2 minutes

First came the news from ICANN last week that domain tasting will largely disappear. Not totally, because the practice hasn’t been banned, but it won’t be free anymore. The ICANN Board passed a motion to

include fees for all domains added, including domains added during the AGP,
and encourages community discussion involved in developing the ICANN budget,
subject to both Board approval and registrar approval of this fee.

The AGP is the five-day “Add Grace Period” during which a registrar was not charged the $0.20 ICANN transaction fee (originally intended to cover typos and errors). A reseller usually got a shorter period of grace from the registrar. A few registrars and individual domain tasters took advantage of this period to register tens of millions of speculative domains each month to see if there was any type-in traffic that would be shown AdSense or similar ads. If there was no traffic, the domain name would be cancelled within the AGP at no cost to the registrant.

Now the party is over, with all gTLD transactions to cost $0.25. This won’t stop domain tasting, but it will be severely curtailed.

Google Puts Boot In

While domain tasters were drowning their sorrows in some virtual pub, Google is about to change its AdSense policy before the end of February, reports Jay Westerdal in the DomainTools Blog:

A confidential informant says Google will stop monetizing all domains if they are less than five days old. This potential new policy change by Google could stop all Domain Tasting in its tracks.

Most domain tasters used AdSense or Yahoo! PPC ads to monetise their temporary assets and they kept the domain if the type-in traffic kept coming and clicking the ads. This means a domain taster will only be watching a visitor counter and not the cash register for the first four days and pay ICANN 25c for the privilege by cancelling before the fifth day ends. Jay believes that Yahoo! will also implement a similar policy.

This is great news for the rest of us. People will buy domain names more thoughtfully and for long-term reasons. Google will regain some of that lost “Do No Evil” cred.

Google to go beyond print ads?

Reading Time: < 1 minute

Kaywa QR barcodeBarcode for netmagellan.comDan Frommer reports in Alley Insider that Google is testing 2D barcodes in its Google Print Ads for newspapers. This makes a lot of sense, because the URL can be as long as you wish within reason – but long enough to accommodate tracking tags as happens in AdSense ads. Google is using the Kaywa QR format seen on the left (correction and more information in the comment). Nokia uses a different format (right) and my N95 phone can read such code. Both images show the URL of this website. This enables my mobile phone to store a URL very easily and it helps Google and the advertiser to track the success of their campaigns. The QR format seems to better facilitate vertical identification, which might be important when reading a barcode stuck to some object such as a parcel. Vertical orientation would not seem as important in a print ad, which I expect to be oriented correctly.

Would Google want a barcode that can be read easily, regardless of image orientation? Nokia’s site shows T-shirts with barcodes. Where else might Google print ads? On pub coasters? On candy wrappers? Milk cartons?

NotchUp opens up to the world

Reading Time: < 1 minute

NotchUpGood news. A couple of days after I rubbished NotchUp for blocking my access when I mentioned the difficulty of entering a non-US address, they have fixed things. Not just for me, but for all comers outside the US. You no longer need an invitation – just go to www.notchup.com and sign up. It is still in beta.

trainsem.gooruze.com

Mastodon