Subdomains treated like subdirectories?

Ash Nallawalla

27 May 2018


I saw a Facebook reference to an article on SEJ that “Google treats subdomains and subdirectories the same“. It caught my eye because of something  I experienced recently.

Recently, I requested the removal of an entire http site in Google Search Console (GSC), as this site had received a manual penalty for spammy structured data – although the site had moved to https almost 3 years ago. Got the notification for a manual action.

Thought nothing more of it for an hour and then I looked at the https property in GSC (which had replaced the http version) and saw the same manual action – but no email notification to date. Found the likely cause (rating&reviews code).

Then a few minutes later, I saw every listing for the https site disappear from Google!

Assumed that this was on account of this manual action. Thought it excessive, but then it’s Google.

A few days later, happened to read Jenstar’s article quoting JohnMu saying that removing an entire http property will also remove the entire https and non-www properties from the index! How counter-intuitive, but then it’s Google again!

What the article did not mention was subdomains. Yes, I saw that our subdomains were also taken out of the index! So what happened to the story that a subdomain is treated by Google as a separate site for SEO purposes?

I requested cancellation of the removal request and the listings were back in an hour! Phew.

Ash Nallawalla

Search strategist experienced in large, complex websites. Ash's Google+ profile

Related Posts

SEO Implications of Google Ads’ New Exact Match

Ash Nallawalla

4 December 2018


Feel free to share...FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditStumbleUponLinkedinemailBrad Geddes has published an excellent post entitled “Exact match is no longer exact match – are you managing the changes correctly?” Although it is about PPC, can SEOs learn from it? It is a timely reminder for those of us in SEO and content writing to be aware of Search Intent versus Keyword […]

Read More

Sherpa for Majestic Chrome Extension – Review

Ash Nallawalla

21 October 2017

SEO, SEO Tools

Feel free to share...FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditStumbleUponLinkedinemailMost professional SEOs I know use for reliable backlink data. Majestic provides a lot of data about the links to a site, including data about the quality of those links. I have used it for many years, from the time it was known as Majestic SEO. I usually enter the URL […]

Read More

Older Posts